L'Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Carbon Black

I've used this eye liner for YEARS and have never found a better liner. Precision is the perfect name, because you can truly get a precise line of color. It doesn't run, fade, and washed off easily with micellar water. But black is a bit too bold for my aging eyes. I agree with the other reviewers that you should bring back the earthen brown shade, but it would awesome if you could add other colors, like grey, charcoal,or navy (for some reason, brown dyes irritate my skin).

Doesn't smudge. Tip has perfect flexibility to create the perfect line. Been searching for the brown color for a long time! Tried other brands. Not as good. So sad that I can't find this in brown anywhere. Worn this eyeliner in BROWN for 20 years. Black is too intense for me. Brown was perfect. :(

So, I was going to give the rating a 5, because I really do love the eyeliner. The long felt tip works awesome, the eyeliner doesn't leave me looking like a raccoon at the end of the day (or even after a couple hours like some I've tried), and it comes off easy. The reason for one star.....THEY DISCONTINUED EARTHEN ROCK BROWN!!!! UGH!! Seriously L'Oreal!! It's apparent by the reviews that there are MANY of us that prefer brown over black. BRING BACK EARTHEN ROCK BROWN PLEASE!!!

I have been using this product for years because it is easy to apply and comes off clean when I wash my face. It has been very disappointing to see only black in the stores. Other products have not lived up to the quality of the intense liner. Black is way too bold and unnatural for this blonde.

Once I tried this eyeliner, I never switched to any other. I've tried others when I've run out of this one, but nothing ever compares - no matter how expensive or fancy the brand. This is hands-down the best liquid liner I've ever used. The applicator is perfectly firm enough to create a line as thin or thick as you want. The consistency of the actual product is great too. It is long-lasting without being waterproof (I don't like how hard it is to get waterproof products off). I wear it for 9+ hours a day and it stays put and looks just the way it did when I apply it at 6 in the morning after a long day at work. I can't recommend this liquid liner enough! Try it, you won't be disappointed.