Almay Intense I-Color Gel Smooth Liner, Black (For Brown Eyes)

-1. It's all dried out. I purchased the gel eyeliner so it would glide on this does nothing but pull my skin do not waste your $$

This is a terrible product! I bought four and I am really unhappy with this- fist, it doesn't turn up from the bottom, which was a big surprise. And it doesn't sharpen, it just smushes into itself. Useless after the first few times. I am starting to feel that my 30 + years with Almay are coming to an end

I had used a twist up dark liner for years that stopped working on my older eyes. (57 and needing less eye makeup) I began experimenting, gel, liquid, etc. all too dark, heavy and hard to remove. This one fit my needs. I use the charcoal. I have greenish/hazel eyes. It has a nice shimmer which brightens my eye contour. My lashes are thin so the smudged looks helps with defining. Plus my hands aren't steady and I end up with brush liners all over my kid! I did think this was a twist up and was confused when twisting the bottom resulted in nothing happening. I used a solid pencil sharpener that I use to sharpen my good color drawing pencils. Turning slowly and just shaving off a bit. I do not try for a super sharp point but not an issue for me. The eyeliner has good staying power. Just let it set first I will purchase this again but if you want a dark, fine line, try a brush on.

Horrible in so many ways!! As a loyal Almay customer for years, (sensitive eyes) this eyeliner made my sensitive eyes water. The old one did not. I was trying to figure out why I was spinning the bottom and nothing was coming out...it needs a sharpener! Goes on too thick also and doesn't last!! Please Almay, quite changing! Stick with what you had. It was the best! Going to find a new brand for sure now!

I have sensitive eyes and need a hypoallergenic eyeliner not many companies have it. I have been using this product for more than a year but I have noticed in the last few months that it doesn't sharpen at all it is too soft and the end doesn't go on smoothly I am very disappointed