Maybelline New York Eyestudio ColorTattoo Leather 24HR Cream Gel Eye Shadow, Chocolate Suede

The black was dried out and old. Could not use it. Glad it was not overly expensive. Picture looked very good but not what I received.!

The product was dried out when I first opened it. I have tried using it several times and it creates little balls that won't smudge. I also used primer to mix with it and it isn't much better. I love the plum "leather" matte color. I have bought several other tattoo colors and loved them all.

I found these eyeshadow pods years ago. I used them as a primer base and eyeliner and my eye makeup doesn't budge. I've even fallen asleep with my makeup on and wake up with my makeup flawless.

I really like this. Its a new product for me and I was looking for something that was easy to apply and wouldnt have to apply a ton of layers to get the color I want. I got it in Vintage Plum. I was worried it was too dark and its NOT. I started with just a tad and ending up loving it. I hope it stays around for a long time. Seems whenever I love something it eventually goes away. I would also like to have more color options. Some green or pinks and blues.

I love the formula but don't want to do a Smokey eye every time. Please, Maybelline, make a light tan color. There is leather out there that is lighter than the current options here.