The Best Pies 2025

Updated On May 8th, 2025

Looking for the best Pies? You aren't short of choices in 2022. The difficult bit is deciding the best Pies for you, but luckily that's where we can help. Based on testing out in the field with reviews, sells etc, we've created this ranked list of the finest Pies.

Rank Product Name Score
1
Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Peas and Carrots, 36 oz

Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Peas and Carrots, 36 oz

Check Price
76%
2
Freshness Guaranteed 4" Old Fashion Peach Pie

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Old Fashion Peach Pie

Check Price
60%
3
Table Talk Pies 4" Apple Snack Pie

Table Talk Pies 4" Apple Snack Pie

Check Price
50%
4
Table Talk Pies Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie, 4 oz

Table Talk Pies Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie, 4 oz

Check Price
0%
5
Freshness Guaranteed 4" Blueberry Snack Pie

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Blueberry Snack Pie

Check Price
0%
6
Table Talk Pies 4" Cherry Snack Pie

Table Talk Pies 4" Cherry Snack Pie

Check Price
0%
7
Freshness Guaranteed 4" Lemon Snack Pie

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Lemon Snack Pie

Check Price
0%
8
Specialty Bakers Country Baker Pie, 4 oz

Specialty Bakers Country Baker Pie, 4 oz

Check Price
0%
9
Freshness Guaranteed Nsa 4" Blueberry Pie

Freshness Guaranteed Nsa 4" Blueberry Pie

Check Price
0%
10
Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Fancy Vegetables, 36 oz

Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Fancy Vegetables, 36 oz

Check Price
0%

1. Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Peas and Carrots, 36 oz

Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Peas and Carrots, 36 oz
76%

Our Score

Our traditional New England deep dish pies use a dumpling thick crust. The crust is golden crunchy on top, and soaks up the delicious broth gravy below for a chewy crunchy experience. (A bit like soaking up a delicious sauce with a good piece of bread!) Mrs. Budd's has been making chicken pies in New Hampshire for over 70 years. Our pies have a flaky, golden pastry crust with tender chunks of white meat chicken, peas & carrots in a delicious supreme sauce. Comfort food ready to bake up and enjoy. If this is your first time trying our old fashioned deep dish chicken pie, or you have been a long time customer, we thank you.

Oven or microwave ready Grade A quality ingredients Made in New England

2. Freshness Guaranteed 4" Old Fashion Peach Pie

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Old Fashion Peach Pie
60%

Our Score

short description is not available

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Old Fashion Peach Pie

3. Table Talk Pies 4" Apple Snack Pie

Table Talk Pies 4" Apple Snack Pie
50%

Our Score

short description is not available

Table Talk Pies 4" Apple Snack Pie

4. Table Talk Pies Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie, 4 oz

Table Talk Pies Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie, 4 oz
0%

Our Score

Old Fashioned Pumpkin

Table Talk Pies Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie, 4 oz

5. Freshness Guaranteed 4" Blueberry Snack Pie

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Blueberry Snack Pie
0%

Our Score

short description is not available

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Blueberry Snack Pie

6. Table Talk Pies 4" Cherry Snack Pie

Table Talk Pies 4" Cherry Snack Pie
0%

Our Score

short description is not available

Table Talk Pies 4" Cherry Snack Pie

7. Freshness Guaranteed 4" Lemon Snack Pie

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Lemon Snack Pie
0%

Our Score

short description is not available

Freshness Guaranteed 4" Lemon Snack Pie

8. Specialty Bakers Country Baker Pie, 4 oz

Specialty Bakers Country Baker Pie, 4 oz
0%

Our Score

Pie, Apple 4 oz (113 g) No sugar added. Not a reduced calorie food. See nutrition information for fat content. Since 1901. Contains: wheat, egg, soy. 4 oz (113 g) Marysville, PA 17053 Specialty Bakers, LLC-2014

Apple Pie, No Sugar Added 10% total recovered fiber. 5% post consumer. Dispose of properly.

9. Freshness Guaranteed Nsa 4" Blueberry Pie

Freshness Guaranteed Nsa 4" Blueberry Pie
0%

Our Score

short description is not available

Freshness Guaranteed Nsa 4" Blueberry Pie

10. Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Fancy Vegetables, 36 oz

Mrs. Budd's White Meat Chicken Pie with Fancy Vegetables, 36 oz
0%

Our Score

Our traditional New England deep dish pies use a dumpling thick crust. The crust is golden crunchy on top, and soaks up the delicious broth gravy below for a chewy crunchy experience. (A bit like soaking up a delicious sauce with a good piece of bread!) Mrs. Budd's has been making chicken pies in New Hampshire for over 70 years. Our pies have a flaky, golden pastry crust with tender chunks of white meat chicken, broccoli, carrots and sweet pearl onions in a delicious supreme sauce. Comfort food ready to bake up and enjoy. If this is your first time trying our old fashioned deep dish chicken pie, or you have been a long time customer, we thank you.

Fully baked Microwave or Regular Oven Chunky white breast meat with broccoli, carrots and pearl onions


arrow_upward