Coty nyc cylinder pencil, 0.036 oz

I've been using the Sky High color for years because I love the bold light blue and the sparkly gel texture. The last eye pencil I bought was almost gone and could no longer be sharpened, so I bought another one online of the exact same color - #936 Sky High blue. The one I received was a shade darker, not as sparkly and marked #936A. Does the A in the product number make a difference? Was the original #936 color discontinued or am I going crazy?

It truly is water proof! I have been in the rain, shower, and everywhere else thats wet, and this stuff doesn't come off! It was hard to remove with the make up wipes I use, but they are a mild wipe, that is non harsh, so I think if you had a different type of make up remover it would be easier! Overall would recommend.

I received this for free in exchange for my honest review. I had stopped using pencil eyeliners because they smudged easily and usually was a pain to use.. However I have changed my mind. This eyeliner glides on smoothly and it's easy to apply. I put it on in the morning and when I was back from work 8+ hours later.. It looked just like it did in the morning. I didn't have raccoon eyes. I highly recommend giving this a try and you won't be disappointed.

My go-to makeup item is eyeliner. I look terrible without it. Even if I'm just going outside to get my mail...I put eyeliner on. So I was super excited to try this curtesy of Influenster. I wore it for New Years Eve and I looked better than ever.It lasted the entire night and never smudged or anything! The color and design stayed solid and perfect and I love it

I feel so left out of this cat eye trend. Thought I would be able to do it with this eyeliner I got from Influenster but it's still an epic fail despite hours of trying and watching numerous tutorials. It's like the eyeliner is too soft and makes too thick of a line and I can't get the point sharp enough to be precise : (