e.l.f. Cream Eyeliner, Coffee

Horrible eye liner. Difficult to apply because it does not go on smoothly. Lumps and clumps. I bought online and the picture shows it with application brush, but did not come with one.

I bought the coffee colour recently, and am really happy with it! Very useful for a casual look, a bit translucent and thin but for the price I cannot argue!

I bought this few weeks ago. I tried to use it couple times but could not even apply it once. This is such a thick paste that can not be apply perfectly..makes uneven line and has no consistency. I wasted my money. I would never buy it.

I'm usually not good with eyeliners but the first time I applied this, it was so creamy and easy to apply. The pigmentation however isn't so nice, it looks more like a faded black than purple, but overall it's a lovely product

given this a free gift, thank you ever so much E.L.F! love how pigmented this is! will recommend to everyone