e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeliner & Shadow Stick, Pearl/Glow

This eyeliner is the greatest! The texture is perfect. It glides on smoothly. It rolls up and down out of a plastic container so you don't have to use a pencil and get little pieces of wood in your eyes. It's vegan and cruelty-free. In the last year cosmetic companies have changed the formula of their roll-up pencils so that the texture is sticky and smeary and awful. THIS is the only good one I can find now. The eyeshadow is very nicely textured too but I don't use it because it has sparkles in it. I'm over 30 and the sparkles emphasize crepy skin. But I LOVE the eyeliner and at such a great price. PLEASE ELF -never change this eyeliner!

I had a few of these in this shade, but they went missing when I moved. Thought I could do without, and tried to find a similar project to use instead. It was a fail. Going back to these. I use the larger side in my bottom water line instead of a nude liner. It brightens more, requires no sharpening, and is very smooth.

These are so easy and quick to use that they have become my new go-to product for everyday use. I purchased the Brown, Black and Green colors and love them all! This is the first time I've actually been able to do a successful "smoky eye" by myself and I'm thrilled that it was so easy!

When I first applied this product I loved it, the shadow stick was a breeze to apply and I LOVED the gel eyeliner. However after only an hour the shadow had creased very badly. The liner still looked lovely, even on my water line. I am going to buy a primer and hopefully that will fix the problem, otherwise I will not be able to wear it. I hope that ELF starts selling the gel eyeliner by its self, I LOVE IT! I have the smoke/black color and the smoke color is so beautiful, very silvery/smoky. If a primer fixes the eye shadow creasing then I would recommend to a friend, if it doesn't then I would not.

I love this product. I picked it up at my local [...]. I have the shadow and pearl one. I use the color for a highlighter and to blend at the inner corner of my eyes. I LOVE THIS PRODUCT. Just make sure you use a good eye primer, this will allow the color to stay and pop!! I plan on getting ALL of them ASAP!! FYI, I am African American and I love ELF colors!