Coty nyc cylinder pencil, 0.036 oz

I've been using the Sky High color for years because I love the bold light blue and the sparkly gel texture. The last eye pencil I bought was almost gone and could no longer be sharpened, so I bought another one online of the exact same color - #936 Sky High blue. The one I received was a shade darker, not as sparkly and marked #936A. Does the A in the product number make a difference? Was the original #936 color discontinued or am I going crazy?

It truly is water proof! I have been in the rain, shower, and everywhere else thats wet, and this stuff doesn't come off! It was hard to remove with the make up wipes I use, but they are a mild wipe, that is non harsh, so I think if you had a different type of make up remover it would be easier! Overall would recommend.

I tested NYC New York Color for free, but all opinions are your own. This is a good eyeliner, but it's not very pigmented. I have darker eyeliners that I like better. This eyeliner is only good on the top eyelid not on the waterline. I kept having to reapply it all throughout the day to my waterliner because it did not last and wasn't very dark. I love the blackest black on my eyes. This didn't wash off easy, I had to use makeup remover oil to get it off my top eyelids. Washing my face with soap only smeared the eyeliner all over my eyes, but didn't completely remove it. Other then it not being as dark as I like it to be I would still recommend this eyeliner to others because some people don't like darker eyeliners. If thats the case then this is the eyeliner for you! It does apply real easy and precise so it's a great liner to create eyeliner wings with.

I received this for free in exchange for my honest review. I had stopped using pencil eyeliners because they smudged easily and usually was a pain to use.. However I have changed my mind. This eyeliner glides on smoothly and it's easy to apply. I put it on in the morning and when I was back from work 8+ hours later.. It looked just like it did in the morning. I didn't have raccoon eyes. I highly recommend giving this a try and you won't be disappointed.

I love this eyeliner! It applies very smooth and creamy, which is what I prefer. And, it is multifunctional. I use it as an eyeliner and as a brow pencil as well. I tested this product for free, but all opinions are my own. I'd totally purchase this product at this advertised price!