COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil, Black Onyx Pack of 1, Long-Lasting, Versatile Black Eyeliner, Soft Smudging Tip, No Sharpening Needed

It was very, very dry. Possibly on the shelf for a long time. Ordered one other color at the same time and it was fine. Am returning.

Stars are for 1.) Because it use to be my favorite go-to eyeliner. 2.) it's not the pencil kind that I use to use, but now no matter the brand none of them can be sharpened properly. No stars 1.)The new formula isn't great and it's not as precise as it was. Instead I ended up with a mess or my whole eyelid ended up black, from trying to correct the mess. 2.)This one doesn't have anywhere enough in it. I run out way before any other ones I purchase. 3.) Not being able to see how much is left. There have been times that I would only get one eyelid done. What happened CoverGirl? Your products use to great now their meh.

I am confused why this is called Perfect Point as there is no point on it at all. The top of the eyeliner is flat. You try to use the edge and it pulls you eyelid and also pulls the product out of the pen. You need to stop and push it back in. I have never seen an eyeline without a pointed end?

Perhaps there was a failure in marketing grey khaki because I along with many others stumbled upon it and have subsequently bought at least 100. If low sales are what you refer to by "sound business practice" then to me it seems like there is an opportunity to rebrand a product that is truly singular at the drugstore. It is the solution to many greying, ashy coloured and Asian folks struggles. The response to these comments seem to miss the point by recommending different shades. The complete lack of red tones and brightness (in fact the almost green tinge) was so unique as a drugstore product and is even unique among higher end eyeliner and brow products. Believe me I've tried so many. The formula, packaging, convenience and price point were nice but the colour was what made it special.

I so very sad that grey khaki has been discontinued. It was literally the only eyeliner colour I ever used. I went thru like one pencil every month! No other brand has that colour, not even similar. The product itself is great, I give it 5 stars....but zero stars to the canceling of our fave shade.