Neutrogena Oil-Free Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Liquid, 5.5 oz, 6 Pack

Even though this product is oil free, it does have an oily texture and feel to it. Not necessarily a bad thing depending on your preferences, but it does a great job of removing makeup, especially Waterproof mascara. When I wear a full face and need a strong makeup remover this is my go to

Very easy to use and effective. I am able to use with a reusable cotton pad. Minimal to no smell. A little goes a long way (if you put on too much it may feel a little thick). Pleased with the ease of using!

This makeup remover was decent but not amazing. It did take off most of my waterproof mascara, but I had to go over my eyes a few times and still felt a little residue left behind. It's gentle and didn't irritate my eyes, which I appreciated, but it left a slight greasy film even though it says “oil-free.” The packaging is nice and leak-proof, but for the price, I expected it to work faster and more completely.

I've tried so many eye makeup removers over the years, and Neutrogena's Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover continues to be one of the best—and most affordable—options out there. It removes even the most stubborn waterproof mascara and eyeliner without any harsh rubbing, which is a must for my sensitive eyes. What I love most is that it's super effective without leaving behind any oily or sticky residue. My skin feels clean and refreshed afterward, not greasy or irritated. Just a few gentle swipes with a cotton pad and everything is gone—no tugging, no raccoon eyes. Plus, for the price, it offers amazing value. A little goes a long way, and the bottle lasts a while even with daily use. It easily competes with more expensive brands I've tried, but at a fraction of the cost. If you're looking for a reliable, gentle, and budget-friendly eye makeup remover, this is the one. Highly recommend!

Neutrogena's Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover does a great job removing even stubborn waterproof mascara and eyeliner without tugging or irritating my eyes. It's gentle and doesn't sting at all, which I really appreciate since I have sensitive eyes and wear contacts. Even though it's labeled “oil-free,” it does leave a slightly slick residue that requires a quick rinse or follow-up with a cleanser. Not a dealbreaker, but something to note. Overall, it's a reliable and affordable staple in my routine. I've repurchased multiple times and will continue to do so!