NYX Retractable Eye Liner, Gray 1 ea (Pack of 1)

Not waterproof. I applied this near my lower lash waterline and it disappeared right away. It was just gone a while after application. My only purpose of buying this liner in white is to apply to my lower lash line and not only it doesn't last, it's not waterproof at all. I'm sad it's such a waste. I'll just use it to draw makeup on my face.

Loved the color. It was very pretty. I kept this,didnt give it away.

I have tried so many eyeliners. This one is amazing. It goes on smooth, doesn't bleed, and lasts all day.

I bought 2 retractable eye liners. One will not come up and the other one comes up crooked and breaks. I'm going to request 2 new ones as I have not had these very long.

I LOVE THIS LINER!!! Stays on good as most of the high end eye liners.