The Best Butter, Oils, & Shortening 2024

Updated On September 11th, 2022

Looking for the best Butter, Oils, & Shortening? You aren't short of choices in 2022. The difficult bit is deciding the best Butter, Oils, & Shortening for you, but luckily that's where we can help. Based on testing out in the field with reviews, sells etc, we've created this ranked list of the finest Butter, Oils, & Shortening.

Rank Product Name Score
1
Fleischmann’s Soft Spread Made With Olive Oil and Sea Salt, 12.3 OZ (Pack of 2)

Fleischmann’s Soft Spread Made With Olive Oil and Sea Salt, 12.3 OZ (Pack of 2)

Check Price
100%
2
Challenge Butter Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil, 8oz

Challenge Butter Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil, 8oz

Check Price
98%
3
Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt Original, 7.5 oz Tub Twin Pack

Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt Original, 7.5 oz Tub Twin Pack

Check Price
94%
4
Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

Check Price
92%
5
Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread, 6 oz Tub

Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread, 6 oz Tub

Check Price
92%
6
Challenge Butter, Whipped Butter with Sea Salt, 8oz Tub

Challenge Butter, Whipped Butter with Sea Salt, 8oz Tub

Check Price
92%
7
Dairy Farmers Of America Breakstones Butter, 2 ea

Dairy Farmers Of America Breakstones Butter, 2 ea

Check Price
90%
8
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original Spread, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original Spread, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

Check Price
80%
9
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!: Original Butter, 1 lb

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!: Original Butter, 1 lb

Check Price
0%
10
Fleischmann’s Original Vegetable Oil Spread, 11.8 OZ (Pack of 2)

Fleischmann’s Original Vegetable Oil Spread, 11.8 OZ (Pack of 2)

Check Price
0%

1. Fleischmann’s Soft Spread Made With Olive Oil and Sea Salt, 12.3 OZ (Pack of 2)

Fleischmann’s Soft Spread Made With Olive Oil and Sea Salt, 12.3 OZ (Pack of 2)
100%

Our Score

Fleischmann's Spread Made With Olive Oil & Sea Salt puts a twist on the original soft spread recipe by adding a touch of olive oil and sea salt for exceptional flavor. A delicious alternative to butter, this spread made with olive oil contains 0g cholesterol per serving, 0g trans fat per serving, no hydrogenated oil, and it's a great source of omega-3s*. The convenient twin-pack tub makes it easy to top your morning bagel or warm biscuit with rich, buttery flavor. It also makes a great replacement for butter in your cooking recipes. Choose FLEISCHMANN'S Spread Made With Olive Oil & Sea Salt for that feel-good buttery taste.

One 12.3 oz pack of Fleischmann’s Soft Spread Made With Olive Oil and Sea Salt Soft spread with rich, buttery taste Easy to spread on all of your favorite foods A great butter alternative for baking recipes and delicious as a topping for your morning bagel or to cook vegetables Contains no hydrogenated oils and offers an excellent source of omega 3 (contains 400mg per serving, which is 25% of the daily value for ALA; 1.6g) Convenient tubs are easy to keep fresh until ready to use

2. Challenge Butter Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil, 8oz

Challenge Butter Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil, 8oz
98%

Our Score

Soft right from the fridge, Challenge Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil is great for spreading, baking, and cooking. Canola oil is low in saturated fat and cholesterol. Use Challenge Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil in all of the family's favorite recipes.

Butter, with Canola Oil, Sea Salted, Spreadable Churned fresh daily since 1911. Spreadable challenge butter with canola oil is soft right from the refrigerator, and perfect for spreading, baking, and cooking. It's soft because we've added canola oil, which is low in saturated and trans fat, and has no cholesterol, to our pure challenge butter. Real challenge. Real difference. From cows not treated with rBST (No significant difference has been shown between milk derived from rBST treated and non-rBST treated cows). Farmer owned since 1911. www.challengedairy.com.

3. Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt Original, 7.5 oz Tub Twin Pack

Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt Original, 7.5 oz Tub Twin Pack
94%

Our Score

Enjoy the sweet, creamy taste of Brummel & Brown buttery spread, made with a delicious blend of plant-based oils and the wholesome goodness of real yogurt. A deliciously smart choice with 1/2 the fat and calories of butter, no cholesterol per serving and 0g trans fat per serving.*+ Use in place of butter for spreading on toast, melting on vegetables, or sautéing meat. Make your morning deliciously good by spreading it on your toast, bagel, or English Muffin – with or without your favorite jam or jelly. Brummel & Brown is a tasty way to add flavor to your food that you can feel better about. Discover the pure deliciousness of Brummel & Brown buttery spread! * Brummel & Brown has 5g of total fat, 1.5 g saturated fat and 45 calories per 1 tbsp serving. Butter has 11.5g of total fat, 7 g saturated fat and 100 calories, per 1 tbsp serving. +Cultured nonfat milk found in the yogurt adds a dietarily insignificant amount of cholesterol. 2023 Upfield Master.xlsx . Excel . Reading View . 5 worksheets . Current worksheet is Product Tracker . Press Alt Shift A for accessibility help .

Vegetable Oil Spread, 35%, Twin Pack 10% nonfat yogurt. New: simpler recipe! Made with real yogurt. 45 calories per 1 tbsp. 0 g trans fat per serving. See nutrition information for fat and saturated fat content. 50% less fat & calories than butter no cholesterol per serving. Brummel & Brown Per Serving: 5 g fat; 45 cal.; 0 mg chol. Butter Per Serving: 11 g fat; 100 cal.; 30 mg chol. Questions or comments? Call 1-800-735-3554 or visit us at BrummelAndBrown.com. Gluten free. 0 g trans fat per serving. No partially hydrogenated oils. No cholesterol per serving. See nutrition for fat and saturated fat content.

4. Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)
92%

Our Score

Enjoy the sweet, creamy taste of Brummel & Brown buttery spread, made with a delicious blend of plant-based oils and the wholesome goodness of real yogurt. A deliciously smart choice with 1/2 the fat and calories of butter, no cholesterol per serving and 0g trans fat per serving.*+ Use in place of butter for spreading on toast, melting on vegetables, or sauting meat. Make your morning deliciously good by spreading it on your toast, bagel, or English Muffin ? with or without your favorite jam or jelly. Brummel & Brown is a tasty way to add flavor to your food that you can feel better about. Discover the pure deliciousness of Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)! * Brummel & Brown has 5g of total fat, 1.5 g saturated fat and 45 calories per 1 tbsp serving. Butter has 11.5g of total fat, 7 g saturated fat and 100 calories, per 1 tbsp serving. +Cultured nonfat milk found in the yogurt adds a dietarily insignificant amount of cholesterol.

Made with plant-based oils and real yogurt 1/2 the fat and calories of butter* Includes one Brummel & Brown Buttery Spread with Real Yogurt, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated) 0g cholesterol per serving+ 0g trans fat per serving No partially hydrogenated oils Gluten free A deliciously smart choice!

5. Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread, 6 oz Tub

Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread, 6 oz Tub
92%

Our Score

Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread has the country fresh taste you love, with a touch of sweetness. This delicious, real whipped honey spread brings the sweet taste of honey to your favorite dishes. Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread provides a butter alternative with 5 grams of fat and 60 calories per serving. Made with high quality ingredients and no hydrogenated oils, Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread gives families a delicious option with a touch of added sweetness. Country Crock Honey Flavored Spread can be used with your favorite dishes, whether it’s French toast or pancakes for breakfast, topping on corn on the cob, or spreading on multigrain toast – it’s a deliciously sweet option with the country fresh taste you love.

Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread brings a sweet taste of honey to your french toast, muffins or favorite veggies. Enjoy Country Fresh Taste with a touch of honey. Brings a sweet taste of honey to your french toast, muffins or favorite veggies Whipped with real honey NO partially hydrogenated vegetable oils: 0g trans fat per serving With 40% fewer calories than butter, Country Crock Honey Flavored Buttery Spread is a healthy butter substitute.

6. Challenge Butter, Whipped Butter with Sea Salt, 8oz Tub

Challenge Butter, Whipped Butter with Sea Salt, 8oz Tub
92%

Our Score

Butter, Whipped, with Sea Salt, Tub 8 OZ Real California milk. From cows not treated with the growth hormone rbST (No significant difference has been shown between milk derived from rbST treated and non-rbST treated cows). Real challenge. Real difference. Questions? Call toll free: 1-877-883-2479 or visit: www.challengedairy.com. First quality whipped butter. Made from grade AA butter. Keep refrigerated. To soften for easier spreading, remove from refrigeration 30 minutes before use. Contains: milk. 8 oz (227 g) Dublin, CA 94568 877-883-2479 Challenge Dairy Products, Inc. 1925

Real California milk® First quality whipped butter Made from grade AA butter Real challenge. Real difference Kosher - D

7. Dairy Farmers Of America Breakstones Butter, 2 ea

Dairy Farmers Of America Breakstones Butter, 2 ea
90%

Our Score

Breakstone's Butter brings a deliciously rich taste to your favorite foods, from mashed potatoes and freshly baked bread to steamed veggies. Use it when cooking and preparing meals. It's ideal for all of your recipes that call for butter. This natural salted butter has 100 calories per serving and zero trans fat. It's also an excellent source of vitamin A. Stock up on plenty to have on hand for everyday food planning. You can also freeze it so you always have extra available. Check out other foods from Breakstone's, including unsalted butter, cottage cheese and sour cream. All products are sold separately.

Breakstone's All Natural Salted Butter: All natural Low-sodium butter Kosher Excellent for cooking, baking and as a condiment for a variety of foods on your dining table

8. I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original Spread, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original Spread, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated)
80%

Our Score

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original Spread, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated) is not just a fantastic way to add delicious buttery flavor to your favorite foods, it’s also what you yell pretty much every time you taste it. And how fun is that? We’ll tell you: a lot of fun. Compared to dairy butter, per 1 tbsp. serving, I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! Original Spread has less saturated fat, fewer calories, and more omega-3 ALAs. 375mg of omega-3 ALA (23% of the 1.6g daily value) compared to 44mg (1.1% of the 1.6g daily value) contained in dairy butter to be exact. Also, unlike dairy butter, I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! Original Spread meets the nutritional requirements of the American Heart Association Heart-Check Food Certification Program. It’s made with good fats from plant-based oils, including soybean oil. Supportive but not conclusive scientific evidence suggests that eating about one and a half tablespoons (20.5g) of soybean oil daily, which contains unsaturated fat, may reduce the risk of coronary heart disease. Made with simple ingredients such as a delicious blend of plant-based oils, purified water, and a pinch of salt. I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! Original Spread delivers unbelievable buttery goodness with no artificial flavors, and no artificial preservatives. Per 1 tablespoon serving, it has 6g total fat and 0g of trans-fat, and just 60 calories. At 2g of saturated fat per 1 tablespoon serving, that's 70% less than what dairy butter has! And when a guest comes over and sees I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! in your fridge? They’re smiling...guaranteed. I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! Isn’t just a good decision, it’s also a pretty good time. Now go ahead and say the name again. Out loud. It feels great, pinky swear.

Includes one I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Original Spread, 15 oz Tub (Refrigerated) Made with good fats from plant-based oils, good source of omega-3 ALA.* No partially hydrogenated oils No artificial flavors or preservatives 0g trans fat per 1 tablespoon serving 60 calories per 1 tablespoon serving and 70% less saturated fat than butter*** Crafted with simple ingredients Certified by the American Heart Association (R) **

9. I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!: Original Butter, 1 lb

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!: Original Butter, 1 lb
0%

Our Score

Original

Icbinb Qtrs West Pk

10. Fleischmann’s Original Vegetable Oil Spread, 11.8 OZ (Pack of 2)

Fleischmann’s Original Vegetable Oil Spread, 11.8 OZ (Pack of 2)
0%

Our Score

Cut back on the fat and calories without sacrificing that rich, buttery taste with a two-pack of FLEISCHMANN'S Original Soft Spread. This vegetable oil spread contains 0g trans fat per serving, no hydrogenated oil, and it's a great source of omega-3s*. The convenient twin pack tubs make it easy to spread FLEISCHMANN'S on all of your favorite foods. Use the soft spread as a topping for your morning toast or to sauté vegetables. It also makes a great replacement for butter in your baking recipes. Choose FLEISCHMANN'S Original Soft Spread for that feel-good buttery taste.

One 11.8 oz pack of Fleischmann’s Original Vegetable Oil Spread Soft butter spread alternative with rich, buttery taste Easy to spread on all of your favorite foods A great spreadable butter alternative for baking recipes and delicious as a topping for your morning toast or to cook vegetables Contains no hydrogenated oils and is an excellent source of omega 3 ALA (contains 400mg per serving, which is 25% of the daily value for ALA)


arrow_upward