e.l.f. Brightening Eyeliner, Coffee

I only use elf liner, the grey color is my favorite, but I also love this coffee color. Coffee works when I wear browns and it stays on well and is easy to apply. Fantastic value.

This product has an even number of pros as it does cons. pros: the price, the pigmentation on swatches as well as upper lash line, easy to remove. cons: low pigmentation on waterline, darker on packaging than online, but somewhat in between the two on actual application. it's very effective is you want a soft and subtle color. however i did not.

Smudges too easily I had to use a q-tip a few hours after applying to remove the smudged makeup after using the first time i used black eyeshadow to help to try to prevent smudging. Next time i'll try the creme never had any pencil liner that does not smudge

I bought this a little bit less then a moth ago, and I love it! It glides on smooth, and it isn't hard to take off! Eye liner tends to irritate my eye, but this didn't at all! I'm very happy with the results. I use it almost every day! I love it!

I got the gold one a few days ago and I really love it! It glides on really well and doesnt hurt the eye at all! It would be nice if they had silver though! Really really worth the price!