e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeliner & Shadow Stick, Pearl/Glow

I love the double-ended liner on this one. I use the thicker shadow end as a top liner and the narrow liner end under the eyes. It goes on smoothly and lasts all day. The only down side is that I wish they had more vibrant colors - something besides the standard black and brown.

The eyeliner moves during the day and transfers onto my upper lid. I don't have particularly oily eyelids either. Works quite well in waterline but requires re-application. The shadow itself doesn't have a particularly smooth application but is still a pretty colour (gold), have to watch for creasing. For the price I can't really complain

The pigmentation is good, but it does not glide on smooth. I wanted to use this as a brow highlighter and an inner corner highlighter. If that's what you want to use this for, DON'T buy this product. It is cheap so you get what you pay for. It drags on your eyes and distributes chunky. The eyeliner side has more drag than the eyeshadow side. I would never use either side as a liner or eyeshadow. The only good thing about the product is the color and shimmer. It goes on patchy and blends out to basically nothing.

I bought this in pear/glow. The thick eyeshadow side is wonderful and I have been happily using it everyday. It's very brightening, smooth and long lasting. I have very almond shape eyes and I like to line my lower lash line/tear area with something pearly. It is such a great concept pencil and it totally fits my use. My only complaint is the liner end. It's a great color but it applies very clumpy and it takes some effort to blend it nicely. It's still all in all super great for the price.

The tip of the eye liner broke after the second time using it. I was upset. I also did not like how it went on. It didn't go on smooth. Will not buy again!!! My store replaced the Essential waterproof eyeliner pen which I loved with this horrible one.